Preview

This URL is for GMJF testing only. You may submit forms as a test, but submissions will NOT be recorded in the database and your credit card will not be charged. Use the Live Version for all external purposes.

Jewish Medical Ethics: Part of a Sacred Jewish Conversation

Advanced planning and end-of-life care are more complex than ever before, reflective of emerging medical technologies, which can often prolong life in ways that we could only imagine in previous generations. As a result, the role of ethics in medicine will continue to expand. However, what we can do is not necessarily what we should do.

What is ethics? Unlike what many people think, ethics is not the study of what is “good” and “bad.” Rather, ethics is the deliberative process where we decide between two “goods.” For example, it is good to save a life, but it is also good to prevent suffering. But what are the repercussions when saving a life inflicts suffering? This is an ethical dilemma and we must weigh the costs of these various “goods” while making a decision. There rarely is a “right” or “wrong” answer.

The only thing that is not good is to avoid the decision-making process in its entirety.

While in previous generations physicians would make decisions based upon their own values, particularly their mandate to save lives, today, medical ethics prioritizes patient autonomy as the most important value. This practice also places more responsibility on family members to consider life and death issues and medical procedures. Without proper education or communication, it’s easy for families to feel that they are making these monumental decisions alone.

In this way, Jewish tradition can be seen as a resource and guide, helping to identify other important values. Jewish medical ethicists are in dialogue with the sources and values of the past as well as the current medical technologies of the present.

For example, values such as physician-assisted death, which is legal in certain states, are universally disapproved of among virtually all Jewish ethicists. According to Jewish tradition, we do not have absolute autonomy, as we are created by G-d. Furthermore, to be the direct cause of the death of another is an act of manslaughter in Jewish law.

However, this does not mean that we must always take extraordinary, and sometimes invasive, measures to prolong life, especially when they may inflict unreasonable suffering. Sensitive Jewish medical ethicists and legal authorities have outlined general parameters, which make a subtle distinction between withdrawing life-sustaining technologies (which could be considered manslaughter) and withholding further treatments (permitted in certain situations). Of course, which type of treatment is considered withdrawing and which type of treatment is called withholding is a matter of discussion among Jewish medical ethicists.

Our program does not advocate for a specific position. However, we believe that understanding various Jewish approaches will enrich our conversations. At the same time, we recognize the diversity of our community and that people will need to make decisions according to their own values. However, the more we can educate ourselves and our families, the more we will be able to clarify our feelings.

If you have a relationship with trusted clergy, we encourage you to have a conversation with them. They will help you consider issues you may not have thought about.

The following articles outline some of the most important issues, as well as provide links to advanced directives and health care proxies of the different movements.

For a basic overview, see Jewish Perspectives on End-of-Life Care: Terminology and Resources.

Click here for Lecture Series and Jewish Advanced Directive Forms

Click here for Educational and Torah Resources

Statement on Iranian Attacks on Israel

Statement on Iranian Attacks on Israel

Jewish Federations condemn Iran's attacks against Israel—the first by a sovereign nation since Saddam Hussein launched scud missiles at Israel in 1991—in the strongest possible terms.

Read More

The 86th Annual Meeting

The 86th Annual Meeting

Join your Jewish community on Thursday, May 30 for the 86th Annual Meeting of the Greater Miami Jewish Federation at 5:30 p.m. to recognize Federation Chair of the Board Ariel Bentata for his leadership, dedication and concern for the welfare of the Jewish people.

Read More

Ministering to the Elderly Conference

Ministering to the Elderly Conference

What is trauma? Is it environmental? Is it genetic? Or is it both? These questions — and more — will be explored at the 28th Annual Ministering to the Elderly Conference, “Transforming Intergenerational Trauma Into Healing,” on Thursday, May 9.

Read More

JVC Launches Shabbat Friends

JVC Launches Shabbat Friends

Spread the joy of Shabbat by joining Shabbat Friends, a new initiative created by Federation’s Jewish Volunteer Center (JVC).

Read More

Stay in Touch

Receive news about Greater Miami Jewish Federation events and more.